Skip to main content
Live pulse60 open
‹ Today's board

Courts desk · 10 votes on record · closes in 11 days

Should federal agencies be able to fine businesses in their own proceedings instead of in federal court?

Many federal regulatory agencies can fine businesses for violating federal law through the agency's own administrative proceedings, and the business can later appeal to a federal court. The Department of Labor used this process to fine a New Jersey farm employer under the federal program that lets farms temporarily employ migrant workers. The employer says imposing monetary fines through administrative proceedings is unconstitutional and that civil penalties should be decided in federal court. The Supreme Court heard arguments on the question on November 10.

Support–oppose split · past 7 days
70%60%50%40%30%
Support60%
Oppose40%
Today
10 votes on record · on Ledger—

Your position

Support60%Oppose40%

One person, one vote on record. Your answer can be changed at any time.

Reactions

0 reactions

    Reactions are public in aggregate, separate from your vote, and can be changed any time.

    Movement log

    • Nov 19Results update every 10 responses · as of 07:40 UTC—
    • Nov 16Question opened on the Courts desk after source vetting.—

    Source desk